Learn / Part 3 · Inside the Financial System

Making Debt Decisions

How should you decide whether, and how, to borrow?

TextStandard

In brief

Debt is a tool: it can build or destroy wealth. Good decisions compare the cost of borrowing with the alternative, set a ceiling you can live with, and plan the order of repayment.

Key ideas

1

Cost versus benefit

Borrow only when the benefit outweighs the total cost, in your own terms.

Make an insight card →
2

Order of repayment

Pay the highest rate first; use a smaller-balance-first rule only if motivation needs it.

Make an insight card →
3

Keep a ceiling

Choose your own debt-to-income limit, lower than any lender’s.

Make an insight card →

Try it

Debt payoff planner

Add up to four debts and a monthly amount you can put toward them. Compare the main strategies on time and total interest.

If below the sum of minimums, minimums are used.

Debt 1: Card
Debt 2: Car loan
Debt 3: Store card
Debt 4: Other
Avalanche: debt-free in
1 yr 10 mo$1,422 interest
Interest saved vs minimums
$4,144
Payoff order (avalanche)
Debt 3 → Debt 1 → Debt 2
05k10k15k20k01234567
Years on the horizontal axis.
  • Avalanche
  • Snowball
  • Minimums only
StrategyTime to clearTotal interest
Avalanche (highest rate first)1 yr 10 mo$1,422
Snowball (smallest balance first)1 yr 10 mo$1,422
Minimums only6 yr 10 mo$5,566

What this means

The avalanche always costs the least interest. The snowball sometimes costs a little more but delivers the first “paid off” sooner. The best plan is the one you will actually follow.

Notice the gap to “minimums only”: it is mostly the effect of paying a fixed total each month, not of the ordering.

Open the full page: formula, variables, worked example and cautions →

Also relevant: Borrowing capacity & debt-to-income, Compare two loan offers

Red flag

Borrowing to pay other borrowing, with no plan to reduce the total.

Ask before you sign

  • What is the cheapest way to fund this, including not doing it?
  • What happens if my income falls?
Build a full card →

Do this week

Calculate your debt-to-income ratio and set a personal ceiling.

Try it · 10–45 minutes

List every debt with balance, rate and minimum; choose an order.

See it in a life

Cases that bring this chapter to life

Pause and reflect

Private to this device. Nothing is sent anywhere.

All my notes in the Reading Room →

Words worth knowing

Debt-to-income ratio (DTI)
Your monthly debt payments divided by your monthly income. Lenders use it to judge how stretched you are.
Stress test
Checking whether a plan would survive a bad but plausible event, such as higher rates or lost income.
Default
Failing to meet the terms of a loan, usually by missing payments for a defined period.
Secured loan
A loan backed by collateral. Rates are usually lower, but the lender can take the asset.

Full glossary →

Companion notes written for this website, based on the topics of Chapter 14. They explain ideas and do not reproduce the book. General information, not personal advice.

Enter to open · Esc to close